Back in March, TCM's Noir Alley ran a movie that was surprisingly new to me considering the fact that it was distributed by RKO and, as such, ought to be part of the old Turner library that's made up the bulk of TCM's programming. That movie is Count the Hours, and it's getting another airing tomorrow (April 30) at 7:30 AM.
The movie opens one night in the house of a man named Fred Morgan. Somebody breaks into the house and breaks open a locked desk, looking for money. Fred is asleep in the next room but this wakes him up, so he gets his rifle to confront the burglar. Unfortunately, the burglar is quicker, shooting Fred dead, and that wakes up Mrs. Morgan, who also gets shot for her trouble. They're not discovered until the following morning when Morgan's nephew and heir shows up and finds his aunt and uncle dead.
The first person the police talk to is George Braden (John Craven), who works as an itinerant farm laborer and is currently renting a small house on Morgan's property. When George hears that Morgan was shot with a .32 caliber bullet, he's scared since he has a .32 gun of his own, and lies about it. His pregnant wife Ellen (Teresa Wright) overhears the conversation with the police and does something terribly stupid. She gets her hands on the gun and tries to destroy the evidence by throwing the gun in a lake. She's spotted doing this but dragging the lake doesn't find the gun, so husband and wife are both taken in for long questioning.
The questioning is so long that George finally gives in and confesses, even though he soon after regrets this and insists he didn't do it. Ellen realizes she has to find the gun so a ballistics test can be done and exonerate her husband, and this is what gets local attorney Doug Madison (Macdonald Carey) to take George's defense. However, without the gun, there's so much circumstantial evidence that it could still convict George. And then the gun is found -- but it's been underwater so long that they can no longer get a good ballistics report from the gun to prove whether it was or was not the murder weapon.
So with that, George is convicted and sentenced to death, and nobody lives happily ever after. Except that we're maybe halfway through the movie if that, so there's going to be an appeal, especially after Madison learns of a man named Max Verne (Jack Elam) who has a criminal history as well as a connection to Morgan. Proving George's innocence isn't going to be so easy.
Eddie Muller, when he presented Count the Hours, commented that professional lawyers are probably going to have big problems with the movie considering how it takes serious liberties with the criminal process. I'm not a lawyer, but I'd have to agree that if the movie has a problem, it's that the plot doesn't seem so tight, or at least not so realistic. That is, I think part of a bigger issue for the movie, which is that it was a very low-budget affair. Teresa Wright, despite being the star, isn't given much to do other than act like the poor suffering spouse. John Craven as the husband doesn't exude much personality, and the rest of the movie feels perfunctory.
That's all a bit of a shame, as the movie feels like it had some potential. With a bigger budget and some polishing, it could have been, if not a classic, at least a gem of a B movie.