I'm always interested in early talkies, even if they turn out not to be so good. The way at which America looked at itself and some of the cultural norms that are different from today, close to a century on, are sometimes quite interesting. An example of this that really isn't a very good film is Three Who Loved.
One of the three is John Hanson (Conrad Nagel), presumably a Swedish immigrant although he's lost his accent and is working as a New York bank teller in an era when this was considered a highly respectable occupation. He works with his best friend Phil Wilson (Robert Ames), and both of them live in a rooming house run by fellow Swedish immigrant Anna Larson (Bodil Rosing). Anna is the aunt of Helga (Betty Compson), who happens to be the longtime girlfriend of John, or at least was back when he was still in Sweden as comment is made that John hasn't seen Helga in ten years.
But Helga is coming over to America to live, with John planning to marry her. In addition, in order to improve his life, John has been studying law at night and is hoping to take the bar exam as he's got a law firm already willing to take him on once he passes the bar exam and is admitted to the bar. Helga likes John and Anna does too, so there's the chance for them all to live happily ever after.
Yeah, right, since we're only about 15 minutes into the movie. John is supposed to be a good guy, but he's so busy tring to improve his life so that he can provide better for Helga that he doesn't have enough time for her. And he can't even bother to get engaged to her the day she steps off the boat. Phil, on the other hand, has no compunctions about putting the moves on Helga although it starts off innocently enough when John suggests Phil show Helga a bit of New York and John can take her out the following night. Helga falls in love with Phil, although he's not as much in love with her as she is with him. Anna can see the former and warns John, but even she can't see the latter.
And then the characters start to make really stupid decisions. The movie starts off in the mid-1920s, when the economy is going great guns. And John spends money he doesn't have -- an idiotic lack of probity for a banker -- first by buying stocks on margin and then putting $7500 down as the "first payment" for a house, a ridiculous sum for 1926. (IIRC, the house I grew up in was a 1974 new-build that cost maybe $50K in inflated money.) When John's stock tout shows up saying John needs to back his stock or lose his entire investment, what does John do but embezzle $10K from Phil's till. (What were bank tellers doing with this much cash on hand?) Phil is absent because he's just about to walk out on Helga after telling her he's going to get a marriage license.
Needless to say, the bank examiners show up and find Phil $10K short and about to leave for South America, so he is to them and the police obviously guilty. And John won't admit guilt because he knows Phil was about to walk out on her anyway and can't leave Helga high and dry. So John lets Phil be wrongly convicted and marries Helga, fathering a son (a very young Dickie Moore) by her.
Five years pass and Helga is trapped in a loveless marriage, at least from her point of view, because she's still busy pining after Phil not realizing he was going to jilt her. John sees Helga treating him and the kid not so well by constantly partying with her friends, while Phil is in prison vowing revenge against whoever sent him up, not realizing that the person in question is in fact John. And then Phil escapes and goes to Helga and John's house for help....
As you can tell from the synopsis, Three Who Loved is certainly interesting, although the plot becomes a complete mess in the second half. That, and it was produced by RKO, who at this early stage seemed to be making movies competently, if cheaply with the result being things that provided product for the exhibitors without being terribly memorable. The three main characters all need to be taken by the neck and shaken to get some sense into them. And poor Betty Compson has to put on that accent. Three Who Loved is definitely worth watching as a product of its time, even if it's not very good.

