Back in 2019, I did a post on the glossy Ross Hunter-produced 1961 version of Back Street. I think I knew there's also a 1932 pre-code version, although I don't think I've seen that at all. I don't think I had known that there's also a 1941 version of Back Street, at least not until TCM ran it some months back. So I recorded it and recently got around to watching it.
In this version, the action opens in Cincinnati around 1900. Margaret Sullavan plays Rae Smith, a woman living with her step-sister and step-mother and working at the family notions store. Rae, however, is a bit more of a free spirit, meeting all of the traveling salesmen who come to try to get the stores to buy stuff, along with taking a ride in a car (remember, this is 1900) from Curt Stanton (Richard Carlson), who runs a bicycle shop but wants to get into cars and would be right for Rae. But if the two of them married and settled down, we wouldn't have much of a movie, would we?
One of the salesmen, Ed Porter (Frank McHugh) is about to head back to the train station, and there runs into Walter Saxel (Charles Boyer), who is going through town because reasons. Ed introduces Walter to Rae, and they hit it off, spending the evening together and causing Walter to delay his departure from Cincinnati for several days so that he can keep seeing Rae. However, there's an issue, which is that Walter has a fiancée in Louisville and Walter is supposed to be visiting her and her family in advance of getting married. Walter is thinking seriously about breaking off the engagement and going off with Rae, and invites Rae to go off with him. But on the day of that departure, Rae has a date with another man who makes certain she misses the boat.
Five years pass. Rae has decided to get out of Cincinnati for greener pastures, which means going off to New York City and becoming a designer for one of the department stores in the city. She seems to be doing OK in live, except that one day whom should she run into but... Walter Saxel? He's an investment banker in New York, with a wife and young son, and destined for good things in his business. But he too still holds a flame for Rae, and she does for him, so they start seeing each other again. The problem, of course, is that he can't divorce his wife because he's in the very conservative world of banking, and divorcing his wife is exactly the sort of thing that would cause him to lose his position. Eventually, Saxel is asked to go to Europe with his family to handle some of the bank's European operations, and that causes another parting between Walter and Rae.
Rae goes back to Cincinnati, and this time actually decides she's going to marry Curt, who by this time has become an automotive engineer in the young auto industry in Detroit. But on the day she's supposed to take the train to Detroit, wouldn't you know it but Walter has returned from Europe and come to Cincinnati since he learned that Rae went back to Cincinnati. And as you might guess, Walter keeps Rae from getting on the train. Poor Curt; he didn't do anything to deserve this.
Watching this version of Back Street, I kind of want to smack Rae so that she can get some sense. Curt is clearly a good guy and could provide her a bit of the excitment she craves since his jumping in on the ground floor of a young industry. But no, Rae keeps making stupid decisions. Sullavan and Boyer both give good performances, while Frank McHugh gets to show he really could do drama which he didn't get to do so much. Everything about this version of Back Street is competently made, but the problem is the source material it's based on.
