I mentioned yesterday that I've got two movies on the TCM lineup for Nov. 10 that I wanted to blog about. The second of those movies is Vengeance Valley, which you can see tomorrow at 2:30 PM as part of TCM's salute to Star of the Month Burt Lancaster.
Carleton Carpenter as Hewie provides opening narration which made me think about Tribute to a Bad Man, about how memories from when one was young are disproportionately positive and how driving cattle out in the fresh air was wonderfully invigorating. He then talks about how the problems began when the Strobie brothers walked into town.... Well, technically they're not brothers. Lee Strobie (Robert Walker) is the son of rancher Arch (Ray Collins), while Owen (Burt Lancaster) is Arch's foster son, taken on to help Lee grow into a man. Owen has the responsibility necessary to be ranch foreman, while Lee seems to spend like there's no tomorrow along with being a rather invirtuous person. At the saloon in town, the doctor mentions that Lily (Sally Forrest) needed help with what is childbirth, but that the doctor wouldn't help unless he knows who the father is, which seems like a violation of the Hippocratic Oath.
So on the way back to the ranch, Owen stops off to see Lily and finds Lee's relatively new wife Jen (Joanne Dru) there. Worse is that Lily's brother Dick (Hugh O'Brian) is there. Dick is unsurprisingly worried about Lily's honor, what with this being the Old West, and besides, raising a kid alone would have been a particularly tough thing for a woman in those days. If Lily had been it widow that would have just sucked, but worse is that Lily got knocked up out of wedlock and she's not saying who the father is. But with Owen bringing money, Dick makes the logical conclusion that Owen is the father.
However, we are given more than enough hints early enough on that this may not in fact be the case. Lee has overdrawn his account at the bank by the same exact amount of money that Owen gave to Lily. Also, Lee and Jen's marriage seems to be one of convenience as she needed a man and he needed a wife. If anything, Lee would like to take the money and run, except that he doesn't have a whole lot of money yet. Dad owns the ranch outright, and despite being confined to crutches (hence needing Owen as a foster brother to problem child Lee) hasn't given up control of the ranch for what are really sensible reasons. Who wouldn't expect Lee to run the place into the ground?
The train pulls into town, and getting off the train is Hub (John Ireland), brother to Dick and Lily. Hub isn't really known to the folks in town, which would make him perfect as someone to bring in to help take down Owen for deflowering poor Lily or, if not Owen, then whoever is the actual father. The two main plot threads eventually come together for a finale along a cattle drive, satisfying at least the Production Code office.
Vengeance Valley is a well-enough made little programmer with good performances and a surprisingly grown-up plot. But it is a programmer and there's enough about it that's typical (if not formulaic because of the plot) to early 1950s westerns that I guess there's a reason it's not thought of as a great movie. There is, for example, stock footage used for the cattle drive that definitely sticks out. But the pluses definitely outweigh the minuses here, and Vengeance Valley is a pleasant enough way to spend 80-some minutes.


Burt Lancaster in The Killers (Nov. 3, 8:00 PM)
Burt Lancaster romping on the beach with Deborah Kerr in From Here to Eternity (Nov. 10, 8:00 PM)
Burt Lancaster and Tony Curtis in Sweet Smell of Success (Nov. 10, 6:00 PM)