Gregory Peck as Josef Mengele in The Boys from Brazil
Gregory Peck was TCM's Star of the Month back in May, and that gave me the chance to record a couple of movies that for whatever reason I had never gotten around to seeing. One of those was a rare TCM showing of The Boys from Brazil. So of course I jumped at the chance to record it, and recently I finally got around to watching it.
Now, I assume a lot of people know what the movie is about. But what all of the quick summaries claim the movie is about is something that's revealed maybe 2/3 of the way through the movie, so I'll try my darndest to do a synopsis without revealing that secret in case anybody doesn't know what the big reveal is. Besides, there are some fun things to mention before that, starting with a very young Steve Guttenberg, playing a man named Barry Kohler. Barry is in Paraguay because he wants to do his part in hunting down the Nazis who fled from Germany to South America. He gets photos of several apparent Nazis who meet a man who, unknown to him, is Col. Seibert (James Mason). Kohler then sends that information to Nazi hunter Ezra Lieberman (Laurence Olivier), based out of Vienna. Ezra already knows all this stuff, and none of it will help him pay the bills anyway as he and his wife Esther (Lilli Palmer) have fallen on financial hard times.
So Kohler fashions a listening device which he gets a barrio kid he knows works inside the big house where the Nazis meet to hide it. A bunch of the Nazis get together, for a meeting with... Dr. Josef Mengele (Gregory Peck). Megele has a plan, which I won't reveal, except that it requires the killing of a bunch of civil servants living in various parts of the world; these are the hired killers getting their jobs to kill their targets on specific dates. Unfortunately, the Nazis cotton on to the fact that they're being recorded, forcing Barry to flee and try to play his tape for Ezra. (You'd think he'd flee the country entirely.) The Nazis catch him and kill him, leaving Ezra with a mystery. Why would the Nazis want to kill a bunch of civil servants.
Ezra has friends in the media, and he gets one at an international press agency to pass on reports of civil servants of a certain age dying seemingly random but violent deaths. There's nothing to tie this together until the second time Ezra goes to talk specifically to a surviving family member of the murdered men. Ezra sees a child in America who looks stunningly like a child he met in Germany, as if they could be twins. And then he learns that the second of the two children is an adoptee, which is part of where the mystery becomes a bit easier to solve.
However, with that recording having been discovered early in the film, Mengele and Seibert know that Lieberman is investigating, and they've got spies of their own trying to figure out how much Ezra has learned. They don't exactly want to kill him because that would really bring the authorities on their case, and Seibert's superiors are suggesting that perhaps Mengele give up on his plan. It continues until there's a climax with Mengele and Lieberman meeting....
The Boys from Brazil has a premise that's actually quite outlandish, and certainly wouldn't have been doable with the technology of the mid-1970s. But the screenplay is so well written, and the acting from Peck and Olivier so good, that it doesn't matter how much you have to suspend disblief. The movie works, and even better if you don't know the secret. It also has a surprisingly intelligent coda to wrap up the movie.
