Tomorrow, August 6, is Diane Keaton day in this year's installment of TCM's Summer Under the Stars. Since Keaton died late last year and TCM had a programming tribute to her, this gave me the opportunity to record a couple of her movies that I hadn't seen before. One that I recorded that's part of her day tomorrow is Manhattan Murder Mystery, airing at 4:00 PM.
Keaton plays Carol Lipton, married to Manhattan editor Larry Lipton (Woody Allen) and living in a nice Manhattan apartment. One night, she agrees to go to a hockey game on the grounds that Larry will then go with her to the opera, a sign that there might be a bit of tension in their marriage. As they get home, on the elevator up to the apartment they meet some neighbors they haven't met before, Paul (Jerry Adler) and Lillian (Lynn Cohen) House. The Houses invite Larry and Carol over for a nightcap, and the two couples seem to get along moderately well.
That all changes the following night when Carol and Larry return from the opera, only to find the paramedics there. It seems Lillian has suddenly died of a massive heart attack. Not that there's much that Carol and Larry can do to console the old guy, who in any case thinks that perhaps he should take a vacation to Florida to go visit his brother and do a bit of snorkeling.
Some time later, Carol, who was already revealed to be a good cook, decides to bring over some dessert to cheer up Paul. He happily lets Carol and Larry in, but when Carol goes to put on a pot of coffee to have with dessert, she can't find the percolator. In one of the cabinets, she finds... an urn with Lillian's ashes! This surprises Carol, not only because it seems like a slightly odd place to keep a cremation urn, but also because Paul and Lillian had mentioned having bought a pair of cemetery plots up in Rockland County to be buried in. My first thought was that it's not uncommon in places with family plots for people to be cremated and have the ashes interred in the family plot/crypt.
This, however, is not Carol's first thought. She has a feeling that Paul must have been lying about the plots up in Rockland County; that, combined with a cremation that precludes any sort of autopsy, suggests to Carol that perhaps Lillian could have been murdered! So what does Carol do? She tells her and Larry's friend Ted (Alan Alda) about this, and gets the bright idea that perhaps one day while she knows that Paul is out of the apartment she can get the superintendent's key and search Paul's apartment for evidence proving that Lillian did not in fact die of natural causes.
This is understandably a crazy idea for poor Larry. But he keeps getting dragged further and further into things, as Carol discovers one inconsistency after another that only strengthens her belief that Paul in fact killed Lillian. And dammit, like a 1930s husband/wife comic murder mystery movie, she's going to investigate until she gets to the real truth!
Complicating things are a pair of possibly romantic subplots. Since Ted is more willing to believe Carol than Larry is, Larry gets the impression that perhaps there's something romantic going on between Ted and Carol. Larry, meanwhile, is working on the newest book from client Marcia (Anjelica Huston), so Carol starts to wonder whether perhaps Larry has some sort of romantic involvement with Marcia. Eventually, the four team together when the evidence that there really was a murder becomes too strong to ignore.
Frankly, the plot of Manhattan Murder Mystery is, like a lot of the 1930s mysteries, wildly unrealistic. You're going to have to suspend a lot of disbelief here. However, the movie is decidedly well made. I think it's going to appeal more to fans of Woody Allen than the more casual movie fan, but it's not hard to see why it got mostly positive reviews upon its release.
