I mentioned some time back when I did a post on the film The Angel Levine how TCM did a night of movies last Christmas dealing with the subject of divine intervention. Another movie that was new to me, probably because it was a United Artists release and TV rights to vintage UA isn't always straightforward, was Heaven Only Knows. Once again, I made a point to watch it before it expired from the DVR so that I could write up a post and schedule it here for a suitable time.
In Heaven, there's a bit of consternation. Apparently, there was some guy named Duke Byron (Brian Donlevy) who was born on Earth in the 1850s who was not written into the book of life, which means he was born without a soul, and was not able to fufill the destiny that was written for him into the Book of Destiny. The angels are all worried about this, so they send one of their number, Michael (Robert Cummings), down to Earth, specifically Montana of the 1880s. However, Michael has to go down as a human and convince him to marry the woman he's supposed to marry, and isn't allowed to perform divine miracles.
Michael gets down to Montana, in many ways being naïve to the way things work in a frontier town since he's been in Heaven for ages, and finds that the whole town is in quite a mess. The town is in a parlous financial state because the mine around which the town sprung up has been closed. That is thanks to a dispute between the two owners, Duke and Bill Plummer (Bill Goodwin). The two men have become rivals in other ways too, such as owning competing saloons. Plummer has been planning to kill Duke, and when he meets Michael, he figures that Michael would be a suitable person to use as the hired gun who should kill Duke. Not that Plummer expects Michael to kill Duke, but this is a way to keep Duke from finding the real killer.
Michael of course doesn't grasp any of this, considering how he has a mission of his own that doesn't involve killing Duke. Michael is able to save Duke from being killed, so Duke thinks Michael is also a hired gun type, and hires him to go after Plummer. Meanwhile, most of the normies in town are sick of the violence between Duke and Plummer, and are thinking of becoming vigilantes to get rid of Duke and Plummer. This includes Drusilla (Jorja Curtright), daughter of the town's minister. Further complicating things is the fact that there are certain people in town who don't exactly enjoy the presence of Michael, not realizing who he really is and where he's come from. On the other hand, there's the young kid Speck who has been idolizing Duke and who is able to help Michal do what he came down to earth to do, although he doesn't quite know it.
Heaven Only Knows is one of thos movies that's really offbeat by the standards of Hollywood in the late 1940s. But I can see why it's not so well known beyond the mere fact that it was more or less an independent film. The offbeat idea is one that doesn't always work since it has to be a bit contrived to get to the place that it's going. After all, Michael isn't allowed to come out and say directly that he's an angel from heaven sent to bring Duke and the woman together. Not that anybody in town would believe him. But everybody in it is appealing enough even if the movie as a whole isn't a great one.

