Once again I went looking through the movies Tubi has streaming on demand, and found another Hollywod movie from the Studio Era that was surprisingly unknown to me, and not a B movie either: the 1931 movie Indiscreet, which has nothing to do with the Cary Grant/Ingrid Bergman film of the same title that was released in the late 1950s.
Gloria Swanson is the star here, playing Gerry Trent, a woman who God only knows how she's able to support herself. It's likely off the back of her aunt Kate (Maude Eburne), although she and her kid sister Joan (Barbara Kent) talk about having come from Oklahoma to New York, and Joan was able to go off to Paris too. In the meantime, Gerry found a boyfriend in Jim Woodward (Monroe Owsley), but dumped him because he's boring. The dumping happens as the movie opens; Joan, for her part has a nice enough guy Buster Collins (Arthur Lake) who is interested in her, but Joan seemed to merely want to be friends, which might have had something to do with her going off to Paris.
At any rate, Gerry having recently broken up, she's given a bit of advice by Buster, who has her read the hot new book Obey That Impulse by author Tony Blake (Ben Lyon). It's one of those "modern" books, with new and presumably scandalous ideas about love and marriage. Gerry likes the book, and meets Tony. Naturally, she likes Tony as a man too, and the two fall in love. They even talk about marriage, despite Gerry's worry that if Tony hears about the previous relationship with Jim Tony might not want her any more. She needn't have worried, at least not about that. Gerry soon finds she's got a lot more to worry about.
That's because Joan returns from Paris. She talks about the most wonderful American expat she met during her time in Paris, and how she's in love with him. And then she introduces Gerry to that man. You probably already guesed it, but that man is Jim Woodward. Oh dear. How to get Joan to be no longer interested in Jim, since Gerry thinks of him as bad news for her? Her first idea is to make Jim and his family believe that some insanity runs in the Trent family, so Gerry goes to a big fancy party at the Woodward place and tries to act nuts. That doesn't work, however, so she tries another tack, which is to buttonhole Jim and get him to believe that perhaps Gerry still loves him and it's Gerry who is the right sister for him. The problem with this, however, is that Tony is liable to come across Gerry pitching woo to Jim and conclude that Gerry was being dishonest about the relationship when she first informed Tony of it.
Indiscreet is an interesting enough movie that probably wouldn't be remembered at all today if it weren't for the fact that Gloria Swanson is the lead. She was big in the silent era, before the pictures got small, and would go on to revive her career with the role that probably made her most famous, that of Norma Desmond in Sunset Blvd. Take Swanson out of Indiscreet and who would think of it today. It's not a bad movie, although it doesn't feel overly original. It also feels very dated, and not just because of its provenance as an early talkie with all the technical things that implies.
Still, I think fans of early talkies will enjoy this version of Indiscreet.