Another of the movies that had been sitting on my DVR for a while is a film from near the end of Luise Rainer's Hollywood career: The Toy Wife. Having watched it, I can see why TCM doesn't drag this one out all that often.
Luise Rainer stars as Gilberte Brigard, nicknamed "Frou Frou" for no good reason beyond making this movie even sillier that it seems at first glance. She comes from a wealthy plantation family in Louisiana, owning a whole bunch of slaves around the late 1840s I'd guess. (I don't think the movie specifically mentions a time frame, but considering later mention of going to Texas and the New Mexico territory to help institute legal reform, that should place things some time between the end of the Mexican-American war and the Civil War. The movie doesn't otherwise bother itself with politics.) Frou Frou, however, has spent a bunch of time in France where she's been getting a finishing school education that would also explain her accent. Frou Frou returns home to her father Victor (H.B. Warner) and older sister Louise (Barbara O'Neil).
Louise lusts after lawyer George Sartoris (Melvyn Douglas), who gets stabbed for his part in doing the right thing in prosecuting a white man who killed a slave. But George likes Frou Frou, because she seems exciting compared to Louise. As for Frou Frou, she just wants to go to the big city of New Orleans, not particularly caring for life on the plantation. She travels to New Orleans with Mme. Vallaire (Alma Kruger), faking a toothache to see the sort of doctor you can't get on a plantation. There, she meets Andre (Robert Young), the son of Mme. Vallaire, and immediately falls for him because he's the sort of guy who seems "exciting", just like she is.
But Louise, having realized that George seems more intrested in Frou Frou, pushes Frou Frou and George to get married since that might at least tame Frou Frou. The two get married, at which point the movie skips ahead five years. Frou Frou has a four-year-old son, but she spoils him rotten. She's also not a particularly good housekeeper, since part of the job of the woman of the house in those days was to manage all the domestic help be they slaves or just regular servants like those British upper-class movies. Try as he may, George can't get Frou Frou to act more responsibly.
And then Andre returns to the scene. He and Frou Frou still have a thing for each other. And since this is roughly the point where George talks about going west to help the new areas of Texas and New Mexico deal with the changes to their legal system from the old Spanish-style to American common law, Frou Frou decides she'd rather go off with Andre and not be subjected to a boring life out in the hinterlands. As you might guess, this is a tragic decision, compounded by the fact that she's not going to be allowed to bring the child with her.
They spend time up north, but when Andre and Frou Frou return, George has no desire to let Frou Frou see her child. This sends Frou Frou into a further downward spiral, until the sort of inevitable conclusion you can probably guess from a melodrama like The Toy Wife.
Oh dear is The Toy Wife a dated movie. Luise Rainer had already won her two Oscars, but was growing tired of Hollywood. I'm guessing that the movie-going audience was also growing tired of her; certinaly once World War II broke out she'd have been the sort of actress who would have suffered a dramatic fall in popularity like several other 1930s stars. MGM started putting Rainer in lesser scripts, and this one is a particularly bad script, not helped by the fact that Rainer overacts badly.
But, I suppose, you can watch The Toy Wife as an example of Hollywood's changing tastes in the late 1930s.

No comments:
Post a Comment