Alibi Racket

One of the TCM offerings I had on my DVR had enough time left over in the time slot to run a short, as is the case from time to time. This time, there was enough space for a two-reeler, and the short I saw was a Crime Does Not Pay short that I had actually not seen before: Alibi Racket.

Once again, your "MGM crime reporter" is on hand to tell the viewers how crime does not in fact pay, and does so by going into a story about a certain type of crime. Well, in this case not a specific type of crime per se so much as trying to make it so that crime can in fact pay. There's a gang war going on in town, and one of the gangsters gets bumped off. Now, since there are competing gangs, the obvious thought is that the prime suspect should be Leo Rinelli (Edward Norris).

But, Leo has a brilliant alibi, which is that he was at the movies the night of the murder, and made it unmistakeably clear -- obviously much too clear by the flamboyant way he got everybody around him to note the time -- that he couldn't possibly have been anywhere near the killing when it actually took place. He was expecting a phone call and took it at a very precise time; he made certain somebody spotted and noted what time he entered and left the theater, and so on. Now, since the alibi is too perfect, and since this is a Crime Does Not Pay short, you know things are going to fall apart at the end.

So police inspector Wilmer (Al Bridge) decides to investigate people around him, such as the rest of the Rinelli family. And Leo's brother Joe also has a trememdous alibi. One is that he's known not to like his brother, while he also made it perfectly clear that he had a flat tire at just the right time so that he couldn't be involved in any case. Unsurprisingly, Wilmer doesn't buy any of this nonsense, and has a wild hunch that couldn't possibly pay off except in the movies where the guilty guy has a brilliant alibi but somehow inexplicably fails to corroborate one precise part of it. And that, my friends, is why crime does not pay.

To be fair, this is just a two-reeler, not a prestige movie. And everybody involved is professional. But darnit if the coincidence that makes things unravel isn't just a little too perfect, much like Lou Rinelli's alibi itself. I've seen some better movies in the series, more because they focus on a specific type of crime that makes them more interesting.