Back during Black History Month in February, Jacuqeline Stewart sat down with director Michael Schultz to discuss some of his movies. One that I hadn't heard of before is Which Way is Up?. Since the movie stars Richard Pryor, I figured it was worth a try, and eventually watched it to be able to put up a post here.
Pryor plays a triple role here; the first is as Leroy Jones, a family man living in a bungalow in California's agricultural region with his extended family including a wife and kid along with his father (also played by Pryor). Leroy isn't a bad guy by any means; he just wants to get through life with a minimum of fuss while raising his kid. One day, on the way to his job picking fruit, he and the rest of the black community carpooling to the job run into a Hispanic farm union protest, pushing for a union vote and a new leader. Due to one of those comedies of errors that could only happen in fiction, Leroy does something that leads the union to think Leroy is putting himself forward as a candidate for union local leader, and not in a bad way.
This gets Leroy's picture in the paper, which in some ways makes him a celebrity in the community but also brings danger. One of the bosses comes for a visit in his limousine and, as you might guess, that's not a good thing. The bosses basically drive Leroy -- but not the rest of his family -- out of town, forcing him to go to Los Angeles.
Even though this was the 1970s when California was still seen as a land of opportunity and people were moving there, Leroy has trouble finding work, at least until he goes into a union hall and the people there have his newspaper picture tacked up on the wall. This gets him a job up on the roof painting. Down at street level is union organizer Vanetta (Lonette McKee). She's good looking, so unsurprisingly Leroy takes an interest in her despite the fact that he's already married. And he keeps pursuing Vanetta, who seems surprised when she finally talks to Leroy since he tells bogus stories about union organization and she gives the impression that she's the one who has no experience organizing unions.
Leroy and Vanetta start a relationship and even have a baby together, which seems like a problem except that in a montage his wife Annie Mae is also enjoying life back home because economic conditions there seem to have improved since Leroy left. And then, things start going odd when Leroy witnesses a shooting at a convention. But one of the police investigating has a ring that hypnotizes Leroy. This leads to a rapid rise up the corporate ladder. Perhaps the corporate bosses want to turn Leroy into a sellout.
Which Way Is Up? is based on an Italian movie by director Lina Wertmüller, who was somewhat trendy back in the 1970s among the sort of crowd that liked foreign films for being arthouse and decidedly anti-Hollywood. Perhaps the Italian original works considering the various cultural differences between early 1970s Italy and the United States. But I'm sorry to say that the American version doesn't work. I don't think it's Pryor's fault, or even the fault of director Schultz. Instead, the fault lies with the writers not adapting the material properly to fit into American tastes and the cultural differences.
Perhaps Lina Wertmüller is an interesting director; I haven't seen any of her films. And certainly Richard Pryor was a fine comic actor, and even dramatic given the right material. But I don't think you'll learn that from Which Way Is Up?.

No comments:
Post a Comment