Friday, November 20, 2026

The Master of Ballantrae

A movie that I wasn't certain whether or not I had seen before but was sitting on my DVR is The Master of Ballantrae. It's getting another airing on TCM tomorrow, Nov. 21, at 6:15 AM, and a search of the blog says I haven't posted about it before, so I decided that now would be a good time to do a post on it. And, as it turns out, I'm pretty certain I never had seen it anyway.

Loosely based on a novel by Robert Louis Stevenson, the movie opens with some title cards informing us how in 1745, one last rebellon of the House of Stuart landed in Scotland to try to take the British monarchy back for the old Scottish royal house. (As you may recall, James II of England was the last Stuart king, desposed for having converted to Catholicism; this rebellion was led by James' grandson.) Now, supporting the wrong side in the uprising was bound to be dangerous, especially with the English having good reason to want to be brutal in putting down the uprisiing. James Durie (Errol Flynn) and his younger brother Henry (Anthony Steel) are the two sons of Lord Durrisdeer (Felix Aylmer), and when the rebellion comes both want to take part it in it. But a compromise is reached that only one should and the other should openly support England so that which ever side wins, the family will retain its possessions.

A coin is flipped to determine which son joins the rebellion, and that's Jamie, who leaves behind a dissatisfied fiancée Lady Alison (Beatrice Campbell). Now, if you know your history, you'll know that this Stuart rebellion did not succeed, since George II was not removed from the British throne. The rebels in the final battle have to go into hiding, with Jamie meeting up with an Irish (still a British possession in the 1940s) colonel named Francis Burke (Roger Livesey). Together, the two of them go back to Jamie's family estate, the hope being that he can get money to make it to exile in France. However, somebody betrays to the English the fact that Jamie has returned. Jamie has good reason to think that it's his brother who, after all, stands to inherit the estate with Jamie out of the way. In any case the English shoot Jamie who falls down a cliff to his death.

Yeah, right, we're only about 20 minutes in, and Errol Flynn being the star isn't about to be killed off so early. In fact he's only wounded, and is able to get aboard a ship for France with the help of Francis. Except that the ship isn't going to France, but across the Atlantic, and the two men haven't given nearly enough money to the ship's captain for the passage, so they basically have to work as indentured servants much like the rest of the crew.

What follows is a series of adventures as Jamie tries to get back to Scotland, except that he has no money or good way to get on a ship to smuggle himself back into Scotland. At least, not for a while yet. Eventually he more or less becomes second-in-command to a French pirate, and then takes over at an opportune moment so that he can return to Scotland. Except that when he returns, he finds that his brother is planning to marry Alison, having taken over the estate. To be fair to Henry, however, he logically presumed that Jamie was dead. How could he have known otherwise? And the English still aren't about to forgive those Scots who had taken part in the rebellion anyway.

The Master of Ballantrae is a nice return to swashbuckling form for Errol Flynn, who was by this time getting a bit long in the tooth with his hard-living years beginning to catch up to him. It's not quite as memorable as his earlier swashbuckling movies, but it's the sort of thing that will more than entertain you for its 90-minute running time. Not an all-time great by any stretch, but also not anything for Flynn to have been embarrassed by.

No comments: